Menus
Sandwiches + Salads
Gertie Bagel Sandwiches
ALL BAGELS ARE HAND ROLLED + KETTLE BOILED IN HOUSE!-
Egg + Cheese 🥚🧀
Two Local Eggs, Cheddar Cheese, Pickled Peppers + Hot Sauce on Bagel or Bialy
$11.00
+ bacon $4.00
-
Best Bialy
Gertie Hot Smoked Salmon, Dill + Caper Schmear + Pickled Onions on A Bialy
$16.00
-
The Yenta
Whitefish Salad, Scallion Schmear + Pickled Peppers on An Everything Bagel
- $16.00 - $16.00
Make it a melt! $4.00
-
The Queen's Madame
Brisket, Swiss Cheese Arugula, Fried Egg, Gertie Aioli, Pressed on A Plain Bagel (Fri, Sat, Sun Only!)
$20.00
-
The Lox-Smith
Acme Lox, Pickled Beets, Dill-y Cukes, Plain Schmear, Lemon Tahini, Hard Boiled Egg + House Ranch on An Onion Bialy
$19.00
Deli Classics
-
Chicken Salad Sandwich 🐔
Pulled Chicken with Mustard Mayo + Pickled Celery, Pickled Red Onions, Topped w/ Potato Chips on Sliced Challah
$17.00
-
Turkey Pastrami Club 🥪
House Smoked Turkey, Bacon, Lettuce, Pickled Peppers + Jalapeño Schmear on Sourdough Rye
$17.00
-
Eggplant + Peppers
Roasted eggplant, caramelized onions, pickled peppers, melted mozzerella, with malt mayo served on a challah roll
$15.00
-
Chicken Schnitzel 🍗
Fried Chicken Cutlet, Dilly Cukes Pickled Cabbage + Mustard Mayo on a Challah Bun
$17.00
+ fried egg $4.00
-
Corned Beef Reuben 🍔
8oz of Housemade Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Swiss Cheese + Russian Dressing on Sourdough Rye. (Fri, Sat, Sun Only!)
$22.00
Sandwich Mods
-
MAKE IT DELUXE!
Make any Bagel or Deli Sandwich Deluxe with French Fries + GERTIE Aioli
$4.00
-
MAKE IT GLUTEN FREE!
Substitute an Original Sunshine Gluten Free Bagel - Plain or Everything
$3.00
-
MAKE IT VEGAN!
Substitute Vegan Schmear
$1.00
Salads
-
The Big Wedge Salad 🥗
Iceberg Lettuce, Dill-y Cukes, Radishes, Cherry Tomatoes, Hard Boiled Egg, w/ House Ranch Dressing
$16.00
-
Greek-Ish Salad 🥗
Arugula, Feta, Dill-y Cukes, Olives, Cherry Tomatoes + Pickled Peppers w/ Preserved Lemon Vinaigrette
$16.00
-
Grain-y Bowl 🌾
Farro + Arugula, Eggplant, Golden Raisins, Pickled Cauliflower + Pumpkin Seeds w/ Lemon Tahini
$16.00
+ fried egg $4.00
-
Add Ons
Chicken Schnitzel $9.00
Hot Smoked Pastrami Salmon $8.00
Turkey Pastrami $7.00
Plates + Bowls
Plates & Bowls
Sweet-
Gertie Breakfast 🍳
Three Eggs + Onion Scramble with Gertie Hot Smoked Salmon, Horseradish, Side of Pickled Onions, Schmear + Bialy
$25.00
-
Smoked Fish Plate 🐟
Hot Smoked Salmon + Whitefish Salad + Plain Schmear, Bagel or Bialy + Lettuce, Tomato, Red Onions + Capers
$26.00
-
Corned Beef Hash
German Potato Salad Griddled with Corned Beef Brisket + 2 Fried Eggs, Pickled Peps + Rye Toast. (Fri, Sat, Sun Only!)
$28.00
-
Matzo Ball Soup
Roasted Bone Broth w/ Veggies + Shredded Mustard-y Chicken Served with A Pickle + Challah
$16.00
-
Challah French Toast
Two Thick Slices of Challah with Butter, Maple Syrup, Powdered Sugar, and Berries
$20.00
-
Blintz-Cake
A Pancake Rolled Like A Blintz w/ Lemon Ricotta Filling + Apple Butter + Maple Syrup. (Fri, Sat, Sun Only!)
$20.00
Pickles + Sides
GERTIE House Pickles
-
Just Dills
$5.00
-
All the Pickles
Variety of house pickles (dills, cauliflower, sweet peppers, beets)
$10.00
-
Fried Pickles
Dill Spears +Hot Honey Mayo (Fri, Sat, Sun Only!)
$15.00
-
Relish Tray
All the GERTIE Pickles, Delicata Squash, Romaine Hearts + Potato Chips w/ Lemon Tahini + Ranch Dips
$25.00
Sides
-
Latkes!!!
4 Potato Latkes + Sour Cream + Apple Butter
$12.00
+ pastrami salmon $8.00
-
German Potato Salad
Smashed Potatoes w/ Dill + Mustard
$8.00
-
French Fries
with Gertie Aioli for Dipping
$8.00
-
Lemon Tahini Squash
Topped with Everything Spice
$8.00
-
Caramelized Grapefruit
Griddled with Sugar
$7.00
-
Heritage Bacon
Applewood Smoked
$7.00
-
Two Eggs
Sunny Side Up, Scrambled, Over Easy, Hard Boiled
$7.00
-
Smoked Fish
Hot Smoked Salmon, Whitefish Salad, Acme Lox
$8.00
-
Toasted Gertie Bagel
Everything, Sesame, Plain, Bialy
$3.00
-
One of Many Gertie Sauces or Schmears
$1.00 - $2.00
Bakery
Pastry Jackpot
4 for $20Everyday Pastries
-
Chocolate Babka (NF + DF)
$6.00
-
Orange Poppy Almond Cake (GF + DF)
$6.00
-
Honey Corn Muffin (Griddled W/ Butter + Jam) (NF)
$6.00
-
Grandmas Apple Cake (NF)
$5.00
-
Rainbow Cookies (NF + DF)
$4.00
-
Black + White Cookies (NF + DF)
$5.00
Coffee + Tea + Soft Drinks
Specialty Coffee + Tea ☕
We offer WHOLE Milk or OAT Milk (+0.5)-
Black + White Cold Foam Latte
Chocolate cold brew, Vanilla cold foam, and Cocoa powder
$8.00
-
Cinnamon Toast Cappuccino
Espresso, Honey, Cinnamon + Clove w/ Steamed Milk
$8.00
-
Parlor Coffee
Hot (Free Refill for Dine-In) $5.00
Cold Brew (On Tap) $6.00
Espresso Drinks (Hot/Iced) $4.00 - $6.00
-
Matcha or Chai Latte
(Hot/Iced)
$6.00
-
Hot Teas
Black, Green, Herbal
$5.00
-
Iced Tea
Black or Mint
$5.00
Soft Drinks
-
GERTIE Draft Sodas
Black Cherry, Cel-Ray, or Ginger
$8.00
-
Turmeric Fizz
Ginger, Black Pepper, Soda + Lime
$9.00
-
Lemonade or Arnold Palmer
$5.00
-
Orange or Grapefruit Juice
$5.00
-
Liquid Death
Sparkling or Still
$3.00
-
Phony Negroni
St. Agrestis Spirit-Free Cocktail
$10.00
Boozy Brunch Bevs!
Boozy Sodas
3 for $35!-
Mezcal + Ginger
14.00
-
Gin + Cel-Ray
$14.00
-
‘Aperol’ Spritz
$14.00
-
Bourbon + Black Cherry
$14.00
Classics
-
Borscht Bloody Mary
$14.00
-
Mimosa (Orange or Grapefruit)
$14.00
-
Spiked Arnold Palmer
$14.00
House Cocktails 🍸
-
Dirty Gertie
Like a Dirty Martini w/ Dill Pickle Brine + Aquavit
$15.00
-
Bab's Breakfast 'Tini
Gin, Triple Sec, Lemon + Boozy Orange Marmalade
$15.00
-
Edie's Espresso Martini
Vodka, Espresso, Rum + Vanilla
$15.00
Beer 🍺
On Tap-
Killsboro 'The Killsner' (Draft)
Staten Island, NY
$9.00
-
Three's 'Logical Conclusion' IPA (Draft)
Brooklyn, NY
$9.00
-
Shacksbury Cider (Can)
Burlington, VT
$8.00
-
Sunday Lager
Brooklyn, NY
$6.00
-
Lunar Hard Seltzer
NYC, NY
$8.00
-
Visitor 'Near Beer' Non-Alc (Can)
Nyc, NY
$8.00
-
Hopewell 'Lil Buddy'
(8 oz) Chicago, IL
$5.00
Natural Wines 🍷
FRIDAYS 1/2 OFF BOTTLES-
Sparkling on Tap • Valdinevola
White Blend • Prosecco, Italy
$14.00
-
White on Tap • Gotham Project 'The Finger'
Riesling • Finger Lakes, NY
$13.00
-
Orange on Tap • Field Recordings 'Skins'
Chenin Blanc, Pinot Gris • Central Coast, CA
$15.00
-
Rosé • Las Jaras 'Rosé'
Carignan + Zinfandel • Sebastopol, CA
$13.00
-
Red on Tap • Schneider & Bieler 'Empire'
Cabernet Franc • Finger Lakes, NY
$14.00